Additional research on the safety, efficacy, and mechanisms of action of psychedelic or dissociative substances is critical. However, there are multiple challenges to conducting this research, including:
Establishing Research Controls
A person’s personality and expectations of the experience before taking a psychedelic drug—called the mindset or “set”—and the surrounding people and environment—called the “setting”—play a role in how they respond to it.2,3 Scientists are trying to establish the best clinical trial protocols for testing how these drugs work in people. They must assess the role of set and setting and the importance of the psychedelic or mystical experience that may accompany use of the drugs. They must also figure out how to measure and control placebo effects, which is when a person’s expectations of how a drug will work influences their response to it.23 Because the effects a psychedelic or dissociative drug are so distinctive, it is difficult to find another substance to mimic its effects in a controlled clinical trial.
Challenging Experiences for Participants
Some people who take these drugs have mind-altering experiences that may cause fear, anxiety or paranoia. In one study of high-dose psilocybin effects in 18 adults, 94% reported a long-lasting and meaningful experience up to a year later, but 39% also reported extreme fear during the treatment session.24
Mental Health Issues
There is some evidence that psychedelic drugs might bring about or trigger schizophrenia-like illness in people with predisposing factors, but little evidence that they cause long-term psychiatric problems for most people.25 As a precaution, participants with previously diagnosed psychosis or bipolar disorder, and sometimes other mental illnesses, are excluded from participation, but this may limit knowledge on the drugs’ real-world effects and safety. For more information, see “What is the Relationship Between Psychedelic and Dissociative Drugs and Mental Illness?”